A Spanish-Lheidli T'enneh wind power project is coming
And the mayor wants to be ready for Donald Trump deportations
Yesterday, the province announced a series of new wind power projects for the province:
British Columbia has given the green light to nine wind energy projects that it says will boost the province's hydroelectric grid by eight percent a year, providing almost 5,000 gigawatts of energy annually, or enough to power 500,000 homes.
That number is roughly equivalent to the power projected to be generated by the Site C dam, which recently started feeding power into B.C.'s electrical grid at a construction cost of $16 billion.
..
The development and construction will generate between $5 billion and $6 billion in private spending on the projects, four of which will be located in the B.C. Interior, four in the North and one on Vancouver Island, said the premier.
Among them is a project called the Nilhts’I Ecoener Project, which is a partnership between the Lheidli T’enneh and a company called Ecoener. I couldn’t find much info on it — it was discussed in-camera (private) at last month’s chief and council presentatoin, according to the meeting agenda. Ecoener is a Spanish company with, apparently, a Canadian office in Quebec City and a series of wind farms and other renewable energy projects around the world. I’m not seeing, immediately, any information about where this particular project will be but it, and all the other wind projects approved, will apparently be exempt from the regular environmental review assessment process which is designed to look into the “potential environmental, social, economic, health and cultural effects” of new builds.
If you’ll indulge me, what struck me about this is that the province is projecting the power generated from these nine projects is going to be about equivilent to what will be generated by the Site C dam. And I recall reporting, back in 2017, about a report the B.C. Utilities Commission published, at the request of then-premier John Horgan, which indicated that at that point B.C. could choose to stop building Site C, which is flooding a huge tract of land in the northeast, and instead focus on solar and wind projects to generate roughly the same amount of electricity. And now Site C is built and has flooded the land and is generating that power and we’re moving ahead with the wind farms, too. I’m thinking about this because last year I learned about something called Jevons Paradox which holds that as production of something becomes more efficient, rather than use less energy to get thing, it simply generates more demand. I learned about in the context of the Las Vegas sphere via this post, which I will excerpt now:
Jevons wrote The Coal Question after James Watt developed the condensing steam engine that used 75% less coal than the Newcomen engine it replaced. It was not an incremental increase in efficiency but a technological breakthrough. It was so efficient that engineers started thinking up wild and crazy new uses for it, putting it in factories, on ships and even sticking wheels on it and running it on steel rails.
LEDs are having a similar effect. They have not just replaced light bulbs but have changed the way we use light. I have seen living rooms with a grid of 30 fixtures on the ceiling and dining rooms where you could do surgery on the table. LEDs assembled into screens have transformed our phones, computers and TVs. Architects have been encrusting building exteriors with them, but there has been nothing ever like The Sphere. Aaron Timms, in an article titled Sphere eats the Soul, describes it:
“Everything about the structure is big, designed to blow you away, both figuratively and literally: it’s the world’s biggest spherical structure, contains the world’s biggest LED screen, and boasts the largest concert-grade audio system on the planet (with 1,586 loudspeaker modules and 167,000 speaker drivers, amplifiers, and processing channels), while the exterior shell contains 1.2 million hockey puck-sized LED panels that can be programmed to create colossal image displays. These numbers are so impressively, almost meaninglessly gigantic they induce their own kind of statistical vertigo.”
That’s 53,883 square meters of LEDs. The interior features 14,864 square meters, the equivalent of four football fields. The estimates of electricity consumption are almost meaninglessly gigantic, too; One estimate on Twitter claims it draws 150 terawatt-hours of electricity per year. A more plausible one from S&P Global Market Intelligence says the Sphere consumes about 95,779 MWh annually. Its peak load is 28 megawatts, equivalent to the power required to run 21,000 homes.
Based on the carbon intensity of the Nevada grid, running the Sphere will produce 46,835 tonnes of CO2 emissions per year.
LEDs are efficient, and it is estimated that converting an average house from incandescent to LED will save about 2,000 kWh per year or two mWh. That means that the Sphere is negating the savings in energy and carbon emissions from converting 47,889 houses. What is the point of promoting energy conservation in lighting when one Sphere can wipe out a small city’s worth of savings?
Listen, I’m part of this. I have an EV and installed a heat pump and those require more electricity. But it is really striking to me that less than a year ago our future energy consumption needs were presented as “megadam OR wind power projects” and now it’s both — and more.
Anyways, in other energy news, new Prince George-Mackenzie MLA Kiel Giddens sent out several tweets (X posts?) yesterday reponding to these wind power projects by calling for more focus on diesel to mixed results (twitter really is something these days).
News roundup:
Mayor Simon Yu wants the city to be prepared if Donald Trump enacts mass deportations.
UNBC offering $350 tuition credits to 350 students to celebrate 35th anniversary.
While October had the lowest number of toxic drug fatalaties in B.C. in four years, it drove the total deaths in Prince George to an all-time high.
The head of the WHL says he’s happy with the Cougars’ business performance.
Here’s a frosty spiderweb on some mountain ash berries:
Northern Capital News is a free, daily newsletter about life in Prince George. Please consider subscribing or, if you have, sharing with someone else.
Send feedback by emailing northerncapitalnews@gmail.com. Find me online at akurjata.ca.
looks like you and I did the same "investigation" into the Nilhts’I Ecoener Project, and got the same level of results. I was trying to figure out where it is planned, and found very little like you.
Stellat'en is working with Innergex under an investigative permit in the Nithi Mountain area. There's definitely a bit more information available for that project as per the google, and it seems they are already into the investigative phase.
This takes me back to the early 2010s (?) when companies were putting up little weather and wind towers all over between Vanderhoof and PG, trying to find the sweet windy spot and get in on that call for power. And none got there, although Nulki Hills was the most promising (albeit had a lot of pushback because it is an important moose calving ground, I believe? Big wetlands, some rare plants/ecosystems, popular guiding and hunting area, non-motorized access, etc).
Will be interesting to see how this process goes without the environmental assessment requirement...
Edit: I'm commenting as I read your post, Andrew!
THIS: "I’m thinking about this because last year I learned about something called Jevons Paradox which holds that as production of something becomes more efficient, rather than use less energy to get thing, it simply generates more demand."
I learned about Jevons Paradox during a podcast on my many long drives to and from the Peace this summer. I told/educated my husband about this since he is the guy who replaces old bulbs with LEDs and I say "hey, turn off the lights if you aren't using him" and his response is "but they are LEDs". Energy conservation doesn't seem to a priority any more. SIGH.
Also, just remembered a tidbit of gossip for you: Kiel Giddens and James Steidle were having a chit chat at the Tim Horton's on 15th on Saturday morning, just one table over from us. Intrigue!!
Thank you Andrew for this excellent and incredibly informative post today - and thanks as well to 4streegrrl for adding more about the wind power generation stuff up here.
I had to dig into 'renewable diesel' a bit because it's new to me - I know about conventional (of course) and remember when biodiesel started increasing in popularity. "Like biodiesel, renewable diesel is not a fossil fuel. Instead, it is made of nonpetroleum renewable resources such as natural fats, vegetable oils (ie soybean oil), and greases. ... Renewable diesel differs from biodiesel, however, in how it’s processed. Renewable diesel is processed similar to the way petroleum diesel is produced, which makes it chemically the same as petroleum diesel." This comes with none of the downsides of biodiesel (storage and cold weather issues, and the need to have at least a bit of conventional diesel mixed in), burns cleaner, and requires no engine or infrastructure modifications. (Source: https://www.government-fleet.com/156621/what-you-need-to-know-about-renewable-diesel). The Canada Energy Regulator released a market snapshot last May (https://www.cer-rec.gc.ca/en/data-analysis/energy-markets/market-snapshots/2023/market-snapshot-new-renewable-diesel-facilities-will-help-reduce-carbon-intensity-fuels-canada.html) which includes a chart showing demand of the three diesel types - which ALSO shows the Jevons Paradox at play, with a slight increase of demand for conventional and sharp increases for bio and renewable from 2010 to 2021, more than doubling Canada's total demand from 10.75 thousand barrels per day (Mb/d) to 24.5Mb/d. WILD!
Tidewater in PG was expecting a renewables facility to come online is 2023 (their website hasn't been updated) that would generate 3Mb/d, alongside their conventional diesel and gas production (https://www.tidewatermidstream.com/our-operations/).
Wow I've learned A LOT first thing on a Tuesday as a result of this newsletter - thanks!!!!!